When Church officials are asked about the dark skin of these Madonnas, images seemingly considered a thorn in the side of the Church, they sometimes make the absurd reference to the statues being dark due to the soot from candle smoke, never admitting association with Goddess. No feasible explanation is given as to why only the skin is dark and not the clothing on the images. This author can attest to being at the Vatican and asking about Black Madonna imagery only to have the Church representative roll her eyes in disgust, and me away, as if the inquiries were certainly a nuisance.
Other aspects of Black Madonnas that seem to be common are similar elements of their history. Some of these statues just miraculously appeared to fishermen and farmers. Others say these dark skinned statues came back with soldiers who had been on the Crusades. Theories proliferate regarding the darkness of her skin, with some scholars citing the Black and Brown Madonnas as originating from Africa, or with the darker skinned Isis and Artemis.
Practitioners of Goddess Spirituality often identify her darkness as a metaphor for the identity of the Goddess being veiled behind the guise of Mary. Some cite her darkness as representative of the Gnosticism and alchemy she embodied, or the dark unfathomable depths of knowing which is Wisdom or Sophia. Scholar Margaret Starbird, when speaking of Chartres, notes it became a center of enlightenment, the seat of a cult of Maria-Sophia, a goddess of wisdom. The darkness of these Madonnas might even be synonymous with her chthonic powers of regeneration. Her darkness is also related to Mary Magdalene and the Grail lore which has taken hold in popular culture.
Whatever the specific source of her darkness, and there were no doubt many, there was a resurgence of interest and devotion in the Feminine which accounts for all the Madonnas and cathedrals established during the Medieval period. Humankind simply would not be denied their mother. Pilgrimages to these images of the Divine Feminine became all the rage, and cathedrals built in her name became the focus of master craftsmen such as the Templars and Freemasons who employed the aforementioned elements of sacred geometry within the architecture of these sacred structures.
Another of these architectural elements is the spire which has been associated with the sun and moon, which is seen by some to combine the masculine and feminine in balance. This cosmological connection was often positioned within sacred geometry, ascribing to a delicate balance and harmony, not to mention an order of heavenly bodies. Starbird believes the Knights of the Temple, or Knights Templar, were behind the design and construction of Chartres as they attempted to restore the feminine principle in Medieval society. She states the Templars, “had access to the exoteric wisdom of the classical world, perhaps preserved in Islamic sources that members of the order encountered in the Middle East. Their knowledge of mathematics and engineering gave birth to the Gothic style of architecture, which spread almost overnight, as if by prior plan, across the face of Europe during the period from 1130 to 1250.” She states the guild who built Chartres were named the Children of Solomon, a direct reference to the King of Jerusalem, thought to have written the Song of Solomon, a metaphor for the sacred marriage. Interestingly, she tells of medieval gypsies who believed the Notre Dame cathedrals of northern France were situated to form a mirror image of the constellation Virgo. It should be noted, that until the time of the Inquisition, the ancient arts and sciences of astrology, alchemy, mysticism, and psychology flourished within cathedral architecture and popular culture.